Jump to content

  • WELCOME GUEST

    It looks as if you are viewing PalmTalk as an unregistered Guest.

    Please consider registering so as to take better advantage of our vast knowledge base and friendly community.  By registering you will gain access to many features - among them are our powerful Search feature, the ability to Private Message other Users, and be able to post and/or answer questions from all over the world. It is completely free, no “catches,” and you will have complete control over how you wish to use this site.

    PalmTalk is sponsored by the International Palm Society. - an organization dedicated to learning everything about and enjoying palm trees (and their companion plants) while conserving endangered palm species and habitat worldwide. Please take the time to know us all better and register.

    guest Renda04.jpg

Could it be? - Butia odorata x Cocos nucifera F1

Jonathan Haycock

By Jonathan Haycock
in DISCUSSING PALM TREES WORLDWIDE

 Share

Recommended Posts

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
Posted

One of the main reasons I emigrated to Australia (from UK) was to indulge a passion for growing palms and to have a crack at creating cocoid hybrids. We landed in Adelaide June 2019 and I immediately got to work producing Butia odorata x Jubaea chilensis F1, Butia odorata x Parajubaea torallyi var torallyi F1, and Butia odorata x Syagrus schizophylla F1. We moved to the Gold Coast, Queensland January 2022, where I've since made Butia odorata x Syagrus coronata F1 and what I hope is Butia odorata x Cocos nucifera F1. 

There are a few reports/threads online that claim to have a cross with Cocos nucifera, but they tend to be quite vague and inconclusive. The objective of this thread is to document the process and provide ongoing updates until the hybrid is either confirmed or dismissed. 

I should state at this stage that I believe the Butia odorata x Cocos nucifera F1 hybrid attempt has been a success, therefore from this point forward I will call it Buticocos nathanii.

 

  • Like 8
  • Upvote 6

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

I used 3 sources of pollen, the first being Cocos nucifera "Dwarf Malay".

IMG_2974.jpeg

IMG_2972.jpeg

IMG_2976.jpeg

Edited by Jonathan Haycock
  • Like 10
  • Upvote 1

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

The other two pollen sources came from Paul Latzias's previously owned Cocos nucifera (Red and Green Samoan Dwarfs).

IMG_2514.jpeg

  • Like 12
  • Upvote 1

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

The Cocos nucifera flowers were dried, blitzed in a spice blender, and sieved over a 150 micron mesh. The pollen was combined and placed in a freezer until required.

IMG_3068.jpeg

Edited by Jonathan Haycock
  • Like 7
  • Upvote 1

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

22nd November 2022, Butia odorata flowers reach anthesis.

Roughly 2 weeks prior, the spathe opened and inflorescence was emasculated, then washed and covered with a hypoallergenic pillow case protector.

IMG_3132.jpeg

IMG_3126.JPG

  • Like 11
  • Upvote 5

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

The inflorescence was pollinated 3 days in a row (22nd, 23rd, and 24th November 2022). Method involved mixing pollen with distilled water and using a sprayer to apply. The hypoallergenic pillow case protector was replaced immediately after each application, and left on for a number of weeks until stigmas turned brown. Photos show infructescence 3rd December 2022. 

IMG_3161.JPG

IMG_3162.JPG

  • Like 9
  • Upvote 2

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

18th December 2022, fruits developing.

IMG_3354.jpeg

  • Like 8
  • Upvote 2

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

31st December 2022, minimal fruit drop. 

IMG_3531.jpeg

IMG_3532.jpeg

  • Like 8
  • Upvote 1

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

26th January 2023, fruits almost ripe. Believe they were harvested mid-February. 

IMG_3746.jpeg

  • Like 7
  • Upvote 3

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Photo 24th February 2023. Only 1 viable seed from circa 500 fruit. After drying for a week or so, I cracked it in a vice to see what was inside (looked promising). The remainder were just stones (solid endocarp). 

I pollinated a further 3 x inflorescence with Cocos nucifera that season and got 100% stones (i.e. not a single viable seed).

IMG_0483.jpeg

IMG_0484.jpeg

  • Like 9
  • Upvote 3

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Those of you that have germinated Butia before know how hit and miss they can be, so I didn't hold much hope that this single Buticocos nathanii would pop. Well to my surprise it did!!! Took a fair amount of time though (photo 25th September 2023). 

One thing that struck me about it at this stage was the thickness of the plumule, being considerably girthier than pure/other hybrid seedlings from the same parent. 

IMG_5048.jpeg

IMG_5050.jpeg

IMG_5051.jpeg

  • Like 15
  • Upvote 3

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

A couple weeks later (11th October 2023), the Buticocos nathanii seedling is growing faster than I would expect a pure Butia to, and is bright green (pure Butia odorata tend to be more glaucous/dull green). 

IMG_5313.jpeg

IMG_5317.jpeg

  • Like 11
  • Upvote 4

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted

As of today, the Buticocos nathanii is growing well. Looking forward to seeing it develop. 

IMG_5492.jpeg

IMG_5493.jpeg

IMG_5494.jpeg

IMG_5495.jpeg

  • Like 23
  • Upvote 3

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Aceraceae Rising Star

Aceraceae

Posted
Posted

This could be another 9b 'cold hardy coconut'? With some differing qualities, perhaps some more favorable qualities than Beccariophoenix alfredii

  • Like 4
Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
40 minutes ago, Aceraceae said:

This could be another 9b 'cold hardy coconut'? With some differing qualities, perhaps some more favorable qualities than Beccariophoenix alfredii

Imagine a "cold hardy coconut" that actually looked like a coconut. If possible, it'll be a game changer for warm temperate/Mediterranean regions. 

Edited by Jonathan Haycock
  • Like 5

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Tom in Tucson Veteran

Tom in Tucson

Posted
Posted

That was an enjoyable essay to read. Well done! I (and I'm sure many other cocoid hybrid enthusiasts) wish you the best of luck in your meticulous pursuit. It goes without saying, that I'm sure you'll keep us apprised of your progress. I look forward to seeing how that seedling, and hopefully many others, develop. 

BTW, I immediately applied to join your FB group.

 Hi 87°, Lo 49°

  • Like 1

Casas Adobes - NW of Tucson since July 2014

formerly in the San Carlos region of San Diego

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted
1 hour ago, Tom in Tucson said:

That was an enjoyable essay to read. Well done! I (and I'm sure many other cocoid hybrid enthusiasts) wish you the best of luck in your meticulous pursuit. It goes without saying, that I'm sure you'll keep us apprised of your progress. I look forward to seeing how that seedling, and hopefully many others, develop. 

BTW, I immediately applied to join your FB group.

 Hi 87°, Lo 49°

Appreciate your kind words Tom, and welcome to Pommy Palms 😀.

  • Like 1

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Palmfarmer Veteran

Palmfarmer

Posted
Posted

Can you basically cross "all palms" together? 

SFLP48584 Enthusiast

SFLP48584

Posted
Posted

Now, THAT is remarkable!  Excellent research.  The result is amazing.

-John

  • Like 1
Tassie_Troy1971 Grand Master

Tassie_Troy1971

Posted
Posted

Amazing 

Love your work Jonathan 

  • Like 3

Old Beach ,Hobart
Tasmania ,Australia. 42 " south
Cool Maritime climate

Zeeth Grand Master

Zeeth

Posted
Posted

Nicely done! Great documentation, I'm very curious to see how the resulting seedling grows over the years. 

  • Like 2

Keith 

Palmetto, Florida (10a) and Tampa, Florida (9b/10a)

SeanK Grand Master

SeanK

Posted
Posted

Thanks for sharing your photo diary of this project. Much work for low yield. No doubt the F1 will receive intensive care until it produces a characteristic leaf.

Cheers -

  • Like 1
Bill H2DB Proficient

Bill H2DB

Posted
Posted

Thanks for the posting .  Well done project . 

  • Like 1
Xerarch Grand Master

Xerarch

Posted
Posted

Will be amazing if it turns out to be the real deal, many have tried.  Can't wait to see what future growth will reveal.

  • Like 2
  • Upvote 1

Corpus Christi, TX, near salt water, zone 9b/10a! Except when it isn't and everything gets nuked.

steve617 Community Regular

steve617

Posted
Posted

Awesome Jonathan, saw the post on FB so I jumped over hear to read your research. Great work.

  • Like 1
Josue Diaz Grand Master

Josue Diaz

Posted
Posted

well, well, well. Great work! I will be eagerly waiting for your updates

  • Like 1
Maximum Enthusiast

Maximum

Posted
Posted

Fascinating!
If it reaches maturity could it produce viable seeds on its own?! 
 

  • Like 1
awkonradi Mentor

awkonradi

Posted
Posted (edited)

Fantastic!  This post is exactly what the topic of Butia X Cocos hybridization needs!  There have been other reports on PalmTalk, but none with this level of detail and continuity.  Looking forward to more reports!

Edited by awkonradi
  • Like 1

Andrei W. Konradi, Burlingame, California.  Vicarious appreciator of palms in other people's gardens and in habitat

Palmfarmer Veteran

Palmfarmer

Posted
Posted

It's amazing! how do one know which palm species that one can cross? Could coco nycifera cross with Parajubaea? 

  • Like 3
kinzyjr Grand Master

kinzyjr

Posted
Posted

@Jonathan Haycock

Interested to see the look and unique attributes of the offspring.  Nice work!

  • Like 1

Lakeland, FL

USDA Zone 1990: 9a  2012: 9b  2023: 10a | Sunset Zone: 26 | Record Low: 20F/-6.67C (Jan. 1985, Dec.1962) | Record Low USDA Zone: 9a

30-Year Avg. Low: 30F | 30-year Min: 24F

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted
11 hours ago, Palmfarmer said:

Can you basically cross "all palms" together? 

Species have to be fairly closely related to hybridise. Even then there’s no guarantee. The attached photo should give you a reasonable idea of what (in theory) is possible.

IMG_0086.png

  • Like 4

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted
10 hours ago, Zeeth said:

Nicely done! Great documentation, I'm very curious to see how the resulting seedling grows over the years. 

Thanks Keith. 

As things progress, I will update this thread. 

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted
10 hours ago, SeanK said:

Thanks for sharing your photo diary of this project. Much work for low yield. No doubt the F1 will receive intensive care until it produces a characteristic leaf.

Cheers -

My pleasure Sean.

That’s the hybridisation game; lots of work for low yield. 

I check on this one multiple times a day, and it is protected from rodents at night 😂.

  • Like 1

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted
7 hours ago, Xerarch said:

Will be amazing if it turns out to be the real deal, many have tried.  Can't wait to see what future growth will reveal.

One thing I promise Ammon, if it turns out to be a dud, I’ll post the fact and not go quiet on everyone. Whatever the outcome, it’s all good fun.

  • Like 5
  • Upvote 3

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

happypalms Grand Master

happypalms

Posted
Posted

Hi Jonathan I hope you enjoy living in the best country in the world in my belief you certainly have done your homework on palms good to see I look forward to seeing more of your palms as we say lucky to be an Australian 

  • Like 1
Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Maximum said:

Fascinating!
If it reaches maturity could it produce viable seeds on its own?! 
 

A lot of first generation (F1) cocoid hybrids tend to be self-sterile. However, introducing external pollen can yield viable fruit.

Edited by Jonathan Haycock
  • Upvote 1

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, awkonradi said:

Fantastic!  This post is exactly what the topic of Butia X Cocos hybridization needs!  There have been other reports on PalmTalk, but none with this level of detail and continuity.  Looking forward to more reports!

You’ve nailed the intention of this thread Andrei. I believe it is a Butia x Cocos hybrid, but I’ll continue the thread to its conclusion, either way. 

Edited by Jonathan Haycock
  • Like 2

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

SeanK Grand Master

SeanK

Posted
Posted
11 minutes ago, Jonathan Haycock said:

My pleasure Sean.

That’s the hybridisation game; lots of work for low yield. 

I check on this one multiple times a day, and it is protected from rodents at night 😂.

I suspect that even in a family with "cousins", like Butia, Syagrus, Parajubaea, etc, some are more genetically similar than others.

  • Like 4
Jonathan Haycock Experienced

Jonathan Haycock

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
29 minutes ago, happypalms said:

Hi Jonathan I hope you enjoy living in the best country in the world in my belief you certainly have done your homework on palms good to see I look forward to seeing more of your palms as we say lucky to be an Australian 

Thanks Richard.

I certainly feel privileged to be here that’s for sure, although I’m not an Aussie yet, just permanent resident (citizenship 2024).

I chose SE Queensland as it’s possible to grow a Cocos nucifera and Jubaea chilensis side by side 😂.

Edited by Jonathan Haycock
  • Like 1
  • Upvote 2

For those of you that frequent Facebook, I’ve set up a group called “Pommy palms”, where many of the palms I’ve seen since emigrating to Australia have been documented. If you wish to be a member, copy and paste “Pommy palms” into Facebook to view the page and click “Join group”.

SFLP48584 Enthusiast

SFLP48584

Posted
Posted

Does the seedling above, Jonathan's Buticocos nathanii, look more "tropically" bright green than does a typical Butia odorata seedling to anyone?

-John

  • Like 1
  • Upvote 2

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...