Jump to content
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT ABOUT LOGGING IN ×
  • WELCOME GUEST

    It looks as if you are viewing PalmTalk as an unregistered Guest.

    Please consider registering so as to take better advantage of our vast knowledge base and friendly community.  By registering you will gain access to many features - among them are our powerful Search feature, the ability to Private Message other Users, and be able to post and/or answer questions from all over the world. It is completely free, no “catches,” and you will have complete control over how you wish to use this site.

    PalmTalk is sponsored by the International Palm Society. - an organization dedicated to learning everything about and enjoying palm trees (and their companion plants) while conserving endangered palm species and habitat worldwide. Please take the time to know us all better and register.

    guest Renda04.jpg

Coconut Growing Farthest From Equator


Palmateer

Recommended Posts

Mine has a long way to go before I'd call it a survivor, but it's been in the ground for 15 months now. It had no problems at all the first winter, which was a little cooler than normal. It's already produced three new leaves this spring/summer, and it's working on a fourth right now. Hopefully it will continue to grow well. I'm at 34 deg 6 minutes north...

Jack Sayers

East Los Angeles

growing cold tolerant palms halfway between the equator and the arctic circle...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would think in mainland Europe somewhere like Algeciras in southern Spain has about the best chance. At 36°08' N it has average January temps of 16°C/61°F high amd 11°C/52°F low. I don't have record figures, but based on it's location, it probably doesn't deviate enormously from those figures. On the other hand, it only sees daytime averages over 20°C/68°F from May to October. January also has an average of 121.9mm/4­¾" rainfall.

]

Corey Lucas-Divers

Dorset, UK

Ave Jul High 72F/22C (91F/33C Max)

Ave Jul Low 52F/11C (45F/7C Min)

Ave Jan High 46F/8C (59F/15C Max)

Ave Jan Low 34F/1C (21F/-6C Min)

Ave Rain 736mm pa

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If Jack's survives long term,it looks like he will have the record.Maybe John or perhaps Maurice in Southern Spain or Greece can update.Another suspect could be Sydney or South of Perth,further South than Tyrone country!

What you look for is what is looking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here's a photo update of my Cocos, taken today. It's been quite slow since it got to this stage. Remember Kai in the Netherlands too. Here are some visuals of his Cocos nucifera.

post-1155-1216662473_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

John, what this is cocos nucifera? Come on :rolleyes:

Maybe Voanioala gerardii?

island Vis, adriatic sea, Croatia. Zone 9b/10a

Temperature low last winter: -0.9°C/30.4 F

Temperature low this winter: -0.3°C/31.5 F

-Creating my own little palm heaven-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

John, what this is cocos nucifera? Come on :rolleyes:

Maybe Voanioala gerardii?

No Pivi, that's definitely a coconut, the good, old supermarket variety. The vermiculite is to make up for the lacking mesocarp, and to keep the emerging roots covered. The pot is just over a foot wide at the rim.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

pot is a foot wide? foot in diameter?

Then this is one small coconut

island Vis, adriatic sea, Croatia. Zone 9b/10a

Temperature low last winter: -0.9°C/30.4 F

Temperature low this winter: -0.3°C/31.5 F

-Creating my own little palm heaven-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

isn't average sized supermarket coconut around 10-15 centimetres.

This one looks like 5. At least one the pictures if pot is a foot wide.

Next time let's see the whole nut B)

Edited by Pivi

island Vis, adriatic sea, Croatia. Zone 9b/10a

Temperature low last winter: -0.9°C/30.4 F

Temperature low this winter: -0.3°C/31.5 F

-Creating my own little palm heaven-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

isn't average sized supermarket coconut around 10-15 centimetres.

This one looks like 5. At least one the pictures if pot is a foot wide.

Next time let's see the whole nut B)

Pivi,

Here is a photo of it before it was potted up. Are you happy now? :lol:

post-1155-1216714307_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

John!! yours could have a chance to survive, mine for sure will not survive our wet winter. Any way it is growing quickly, even though

we are not having a real summer at all, temperatures are arround 22ºC when they use to be arround 35ºC at this time of the year. My coconut comes from the supermarket too, hahaha.

post-1359-1216719204_thumb.jpg

Best wishes.

"Not the straight angle that attracts me, nor straight, hard, inflexible, created by man. What attracts me is the free and sensual curve, the curves that find in the mountains of my country, in the course of its winding rivers, the sea waves, the body of the woman preferred. Curves is done throughout the universe, the universe of Einstein's curved." -Oscar Niemeyer

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pivi,

Here is a photo of it before it was potted up. Are you happy now? :lol:

:D

island Vis, adriatic sea, Croatia. Zone 9b/10a

Temperature low last winter: -0.9°C/30.4 F

Temperature low this winter: -0.3°C/31.5 F

-Creating my own little palm heaven-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

John,I know you are a purist but could you not locate a 5 footer from the Canaries and plant it next to your potted Coconut?

What you look for is what is looking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

John,I know you are a purist but could you not locate a 5 footer from the Canaries and plant it next to your potted Coconut?

Being the purist, I would naturally construct my own Kon-Tiki raft, and sail there to fetch one back. :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey i thought the coconut had to have the outer green on it before it would germinate and not just the hard shell !!

Old Beach ,Hobart
Tasmania ,Australia. 42 " south
Cool Maritime climate

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey i thought the coconut had to have the outer green on it before it would germinate and not just the hard shell !!

Troy,

They will germinate if you're lucky enough. Once potted up, it helps to keep the endocarp well covered. On moist sand/soil and exposed to sunlight, the unprotected endocarp can easily split, since it has no fibrous mesocarp to control the expanding and contracting that occurs without it. The "outer green" is the exocarp.

Useful link: Edible Palm Fruits

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

I now believe the most likely suspect for growing the furthest Norther Coconut will be the Azores.The Latitude is between 37/39 North and it's climate is directly affected by the warm waters of the Gulfstream.While not as warm as Bermuda,take a look at Michael's Travel Log on the Azores for tropical specifics.Using Cristobal's techniques,I believe world record success is possible.

What you look for is what is looking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

HERE IS A HOUSE A FRIEND OF MINE IS BUILDING ON SANTA MARIA...LOOKS A LITTLE DESOLATE.

PDnGft6trCoN29gHqbQpW8va1ZM111oz030.jpg

The weight of lies will bring you down / And follow you to every town / Cause nothin happens here

That doesn't happen there / So when you run make sure you run / To something and not away from

Cause lies don't need an aero plane / To chase you anywhere

--Avett Bros

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a small coconut growing in a pot in my garden - very sheltered warm and facing north.

Latitude of Melbourne is 37*49'S.

I moved it to the front porch which also faces north and someone stole it!

Laurie

Melboure, Australia

Lat: 37.82 Degrees South

Long: 144.04 Degrees East

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a small coconut growing in a pot in my garden - very sheltered warm and facing north.

Latitude of Melbourne is 37*49'S.

I moved it to the front porch which also faces north and someone stole it!

<---hugging Laurie ......whaat? freaking lil pea brained thieves!! I hope the get white fly "everywhere" :angry:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Are there no coconuts planted in the south of Spain??? Like in Marbella or Torremolinas???? Is the climate warm enougth there... I see they do have some historic record cold temps that would kill a coocnut.... Jv

Jv in San Antonio Texas / Zone 8/extremes past 29 yrs: 117F (47.2C) / 8F (-13.3C)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
Are there no coconuts planted in the south of Spain??? Like in Marbella or Torremolinas???? Is the climate warm enougth there... I see they do have some historic record cold temps that would kill a coocnut.... Jv

In the south of Spain (Andalucian) the coconut palms always died. I heard about a coconut palm in Almuñecar 36º 44' (Granada) but it was covered with plastics in winter...

Is possible there are some coconut palm in Porto Santo Island (north of Madeira) 33ºN but I don´t know if there are some in Azores...

Gran Canaria

27º45'N 15'35ºW

Zone 11

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Since we are on the subject of SoCal palms does anyone have any (current) pictures of the one in San Clemente or Newport Beach? The last pictures I seen someone did one heck of a prune job. :hmm:

By the way San Diego Zoo has had one in the ground for a few years. Its on the south side of a building in the reptile area. I sent an E-mail to the keepers and they responded saying they put it there a few years back because it out grew the greenhouse it was in. It doesnt look happy but its alive, It looks like its starting to establish. :drool:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

These are growing in New Smyrna Beach, Florida, on the north causway, going to the beachside, Ed

post-3109-1232140591_thumb.jpg

post-3109-1232140616_thumb.jpg

MOSQUITO LAGOON

Oak_Hill.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Checking Ponta Delgada,Azores for Nov/2008,Dec/2008 and Jan/2009 so far:

Nov/2008-High-71F;Low-53F/Average=64F

Dec/2008-High-68 F;Low-50F/Average=60F

Jan/2009-(so far)-High-66F;Low-50F/Average=60F

Latitude/37.7 North

Are Coconuts possible?

What you look for is what is looking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ocean currents certainly do make a difference! Lima, Peru is only about 10 deg south of the equator, and while a few coconuts are growing all the ones I have seen there, especially in the new ocean front beach parks, looked quite stunted. One exception is a very nice coco palm growing a central park square right near the edge of the beautifully restored old colonial section of central Lima. That cold Humboldt Current from Antartica on the west coast of South America makes the climate of the area there of just 10 deg south latitude more like Santa Barbara, CA, than the tropics. There is a bit of summer heat and humidity, but otherwise there is cold ocean fog which moves inland at night and sometimes stays. A bit farther south of Lima where the cold current is less in evidence (perhape farther from the coast) like at Ica where ones flies out to see the Nasca Lines there are many very healthy and beautiful coconut palms where they can be irrigated. This area is in the northern reaches of the Atacama Desert -- reputed to be the driest place on our planet.

garrin in hawaii

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Azores are not warm enough for Coconuts to grow.

However, volcanism is still very much active in these islands. There

are places in most islands where the soil is warm to the touch and water boils in pools.

There is a sheltered valley, in the largest island, that almost looks like Hawaii from a distance.

The soil is rich and deep and stream carry warm water down to the sea.

It would interesting to try growing a coconut there...

Algarve, Portugal

Zone 10.

Mediterranean Climate moderated by the Atlantic Ocean

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

top

Tom
Mid-Pinellas (St. Petersburg) Florida, USA

Member of Palm Society 1973-2012
Gizella Kopsick Palm Arboretum development 1977-1991
Chapter President 1983-84
Palm Society Director 1984-88

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Also Bubba.

Further to the Onassis' question:

Onassis private island is called Skorpios. It is located in Northwest Greece, South of Patras. The lattitude is 38 degrees, USDA 10a, winter water temps as high as maybe 17. Those temps are still warmer than the water across the street from the Newport Beach coconut.

Onassis spent 5 years with a large crew building his island paradise. He had unlimited resources - BILLIONS of dollars, a shipping empire, hell even an international airline - which by the way, is the only domestic service to function within a nation composed largely of islands ( the standard joke in Greece is that passenger planes often land on islands with nothing more than a crew and a shipment of Athens newspapers ).

Bringing 100 or 200 coconut trees to turn his island retreat into a miniature Jamaica would have been no problem for this man. Repeating the process every year would also not be a problem.

One further note, pictures of the island I have located via google show little sign of any palm other than what appears to be a standard mature edible date palm - readily avaialable, 150% hardy and cheap as hell. Perhaps pictures exist of a Coconut-lined beach, but I haven't seen one.

You can correct me on this since you live in Greece, but I would think that the south coast of Crete wuld be your best chance of growing coconuts.

Coastal San Diego, California

Z10b

Dry summer subtropical/Mediterranean

warm summer/mild winter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Epicure,

On the pure basis of latitude, Southern Crete can't be disputed.

I have been in with discussion with a Cretan palm lover ( he's growing 150 species ) about RPW.

Our discussions have been limited to RPW at the moment ( our problem has clearly reached epidemic proportions ). When I get a chance, I will ask him about any attempts he has made or knows of.

Southern Crete is slightly warmer than us. However, our water temperatures are a fair bit higher warmer than theirs on my side of Rhodes. In Prassinissi ( Southern tip of Rhodes ) where the Aegean Sea meets the mediterranean, the temperature difference is quite clear. I like to think our water temperatures give Rhodes a big advantage ( although the opposite may be true due to the warm waters contribution to winter rainfall ).

One more factor that I put to our advantage in Rhodes is the fact we are statistically the sunniest place in Greece as well as the whole of Europe ( 308 days of sun per year on average ). Greek mythology refers to Rhodes as the home of Helios ( god of the sun ).

Regards

Maurice

Edited by mlovecan

Lardos, Greece ( Island of Rhodes ) 10B

1.9 km from Mediterannean Sea

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maurice,Please go for it! You and John from Andulsia will battle for the trophy unless we find someone growing a Coconut in Eureka.

What you look for is what is looking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always throught that soil temps above 60f and winter air temps above freezing were the primary environmental factors when attempting to grow a coconut .... But there has got to be more to it.

This past winter I did an experiment.

To Begin with, early last spring I planted 3 dwarf Malay seeds, each into its own 15 gal pot filled wih store bought potting soil.... Kept them indoors to sprout.

By Late April, They had all grown at least one leaf I put them into the full sun outdoors at a time when the days were around 73f and the night in the upper 40's.... They continued to grow fine. And all summer long our hot desert climate with 100f plus happening on many days..... and we had extremly low humidity which is the norm in the valley.

All three palms grew quite rapidly.

About Thanksgiving time when the nights started to get cold, I brought 2 of the palms indoors under a fouresant light for the winter.

The third one I plancesd on an electric seed warming mat and wrapped the entire pot with a blanket for insulation. That kept the roots at the bottom of the pot around 90f all during the winter and at the soil surface at 63f to 70 degrees... warm even during our coldest spells. It was placed in a warm spot on my covered patio close my house.

Our days this winter were a little above average... Dec was about 56f/39f average and Jan was 60f/39f average.

22 days in Dec/Jan were above 60f for highs.... still , by the middle of Jan... the palm was dead. The lowest temps the leaves experienced were 35f. And the soil never dropped below 63f

My conclusion, not only must the soil stay warm during the winter for them to survive.... Also the air temp must be warm enough for leaf growth, which apparently was not the case with my experiment. My air temp was too cold for survival.

The 2 indoors palms are doing fine..... my experimentations will continue. They go back outside in a week or so.

Jeff

Modesto, CA USDA 9b

July/August average 95f/63f

Dec/Jan average 55f/39f

Average lowest winter temp 27f

Record low temp 18f

Record high temp 113f

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jeff,That is the kind of experimentation that is bound to yield results.I believe Coconuts stop photosynthesis at either 50F or 60F.It is not a cold night or two that kills the coconut in Ca. or other Mediterrean climates but rather the long string of temperatures below 50F even though there is no frost.They thrive in natural hot/humid places and do not like the cool.That stated,folks like you innovating can overcome almost any apparent issue.

What you look for is what is looking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jeff,That is the kind of experimentation that is bound to yield results.I believe Coconuts stop photosynthesis at either 50F or 60F.It is not a cold night or two that kills the coconut in Ca. or other Mediterrean climates but rather the long string of temperatures below 50F even though there is no frost.They thrive in natural hot/humid places and do not like the cool.That stated,folks like you innovating can overcome almost any apparent issue.

Interesting comments Bubba. Perhaps others could expand on them.

Our "winter" - December thru February- has now passed and we are experiencing daily highs

of > 70

Bearing Bubba's information in mind I have compiled the following weather data:

Month Days Hi < 60 Days Hi < 50 Days low < 50 Lowest Temp

December 3 0 10 41

January 6 0 6 41

February 16 0 16 42

Bear in mind, 14 of the 16 February days that did not reach 60 and we dipped under 50 at night were back-to-back and accompanied by quite a bit of rain.

Perhaps Bubba, Tyrone and others can comment on this data and my chances to be successful with a "proper" coconut tree and not just the Dutch greenhouse-produced supermarket variety that come out of summer quite worse for wear.

Lardos, Greece ( Island of Rhodes ) 10B

1.9 km from Mediterannean Sea

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bearing Bubba's information in mind I have compiled the following weather data:

Month Days Hi < 60 Days Hi < 50 Days low < 50 Lowest Temp

December 3 0 10 41

January 6 0 6 41

February 16 0 16 42

Bear in mind, 14 of the 16 February days that did not reach 60 and we dipped under 50 at night were back-to-back and accompanied by quite a bit of rain.

Perhaps Bubba, Tyrone and others can comment on this data and my chances to be successful with a "proper" coconut tree and not just the Dutch greenhouse-produced supermarket variety that come out of summer quite worse for wear.

Maurice - that looks pretty similar to my average winter, here are similar numbers for my location this year:

Dec: 10 days with hi below 15C, 1 day with hi below 10C, 19 days with low below 10C, extreme low 3C

Jan: 1 day with hi below 15C, 0 days with hi below 10C, 14 days with low below 10C, extreme low 5C

Feb: 7 days with hi below 15C, 0 days with hi below 10C, 15 days with low below 10C, extreme low 3C

In general I think this winter has been a little cooler than average (except for a very warm January). I've had a Cocos in the ground for two years now and it's been growing quite well. Also, I've never given the Cocos any protection from rain or cold.

Jack Sayers

East Los Angeles

growing cold tolerant palms halfway between the equator and the arctic circle...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes Jack, I would say your winter is quite comparable to mine.

However, in my time in California ( 91 thru 93 ), I only saw the once - early February 92 when California rains could be comparable to our winter rains ( they were plucking people off the roofs of their flooded cars with helicopters ). I don't think I can avoid some form of rain protection.

What I am envisioning is a 4' x 4' slab of black marble ( fortunately marble here is as cheap as rocks) with a hole cut in the middle for the palm.

I saw some holland greenhouse-grown cocos at a Budapest building center last week.

Might as well just pick a couple up today bring them home to Greece next week. I'll have my gardener work with them through to June and then just take the best of the two for the marble treatment. If the worse of the two is not looking so bad, I will just plant it on a friend's beach property and see what happens.

As John mentioned in posting his newly-acquired coco on another thread, now is the best time for acclimation, our temps are only starting to warm up - 70-75 vs. summertime 100-120 - frying them would be more difficult right now.

Lardos, Greece ( Island of Rhodes ) 10B

1.9 km from Mediterannean Sea

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok Bubba,

After sitting out on trying to grow a coconut for 4 years now, I'm back in the game.

Cost: about 17 Euro, 20 cents...what have I got to loose.

post-213-1236439046_thumb.jpg

Edited by mlovecan

Lardos, Greece ( Island of Rhodes ) 10B

1.9 km from Mediterannean Sea

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maurice,You,John and Jack going for the trophy! Watch out for those Kiwi's,Tazmainian's or Azorians growing out volcano holes.To the victor go the spoils!Do It!

What you look for is what is looking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...