Jump to content
teddytn

Different forms of Needle palm

Recommended Posts

teddytn

I remember seeing pictures of needle palms with a vertical solitary trunk and no lower fronds a long time ago. People were calling it a Bull needle. I’ve always been familiar with the “normal” clumping form which seems to grow wider with offsets as fast as it grows tall. I have one that’s been slow to grow period and only has a few small pups, but I don’t think is a “bull”. One normal clumping form and a small new clumping form. What’s everyone’s experience with the 2 different types? Let’s see them!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Will Simpson

I have one that I'm not sure what it is . It looks like a bushy one with off sets but I wonder what it would look like if I pruned down  the offsets . I've been thinking about doing that too . I bet a lot of the bulls are done like that or they are  really  old . 

I've heard of some people digging up the offsets and planting them elsewhere . That would create a " bull " in time .

Edited by Will Simpson

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teddytn
27 minutes ago, Will Simpson said:

I have one that I'm not sure what it is . It looks like a bushy one with off sets but I wonder what it would look like if I pruned down  the offsets . I've been thinking about doing that too . I bet a lot of the bulls are done like that or they are  really  old . 

I've heard of some people digging up the offsets and planting them elsewhere . That would create a " bull " in time .

Yeah that makes sense, they hold fronds forever, it seems like my biggest one has straps leaves still on it from the day I planted it like 8 years ago.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jtee
23 hours ago, teddytn said:

I remember seeing pictures of needle palms with a vertical solitary trunk and no lower fronds a long time ago. People were calling it a Bull needle. I’ve always been familiar with the “normal” clumping form which seems to grow wider with offsets as fast as it grows tall. I have one that’s been slow to grow period and only has a few small pups, but I don’t think is a “bull”. One normal clumping form and a small new clumping form. What’s everyone’s experience with the 2 different types? Let’s see them!!!

I messaged you

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Will Simpson

My bull is about 7' tall . I've got to blow the leaves off of the trunk so it is more visible . I might take a picture of it after I blow off the trunk in the next couple days , then I can really see how fat the trunk is .

 

 

IMG_0049.thumb.JPG.985c4d11fb20c72d6a2c505deb497bbc.JPG

  • Like 4
  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teddytn
4 hours ago, Will Simpson said:

My bull is about 7' tall . I've got to blow the leaves off of the trunk so it is more visible . I might take a picture of it after I blow off the trunk in the next couple days , then I can really see how fat the trunk is .

 

 

IMG_0049.thumb.JPG.985c4d11fb20c72d6a2c505deb497bbc.JPG

Just a few main trunks or just one? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teddytn

Here’s the three I have. That’s the biggest one. Probably has 8 main trunks all 12” high, and 15 small offsets ringing the perimeter. B72E5251-5A88-435A-9A12-AA05EABA8685.thumb.jpeg.407d1d8cf760e6e221e25a71ec94f4d2.jpeg375FA690-7BB7-4F38-8E0C-EBF4C7BBA7A7.thumb.jpeg.de7b7e0dd073723e6ba47e3851834d22.jpeg82886492-CFAD-4FE7-BAAC-C5AFC96AFA85.thumb.jpeg.e36c1268b956c6eb38843ccd2de23fa0.jpegThat’s the smallest one looks normal main trunk 3 offsets.EF9EB975-938A-4BCA-9ECD-BB170FE66667.thumb.jpeg.8c08f5ddd121d6ecd6aed27ddb4f5e12.jpegThe middle size one I have below has only been in the ground 6 years and the biggest one 7 years. The one below only has 2 main trunks and one offset each. Instead of multiplying it seems to just add growth vertical. May be a contender for a bull72A18BB1-1B50-46E4-ACF9-14A251BFCF32.thumb.jpeg.19c8161082efc5361a56d1d8856e79c0.jpeg

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Manalto

Teddy, the needle in your top photo looks nice and dark and glossy. Do you know the reason? Grown in the shade?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teddytn
11 hours ago, Manalto said:

Teddy, the needle in your top photo looks nice and dark and glossy. Do you know the reason? Grown in the shade?

It gets partially shaded by the porch above in the mornings, but gets full afternoon sun. That pic was the north side of the plant may have something to do with it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Will Simpson
14 hours ago, teddytn said:

Just a few main trunks or just one? 

It's just one main trunk , and it really isn't a bull yet . It might look interesting if I prune off the offsets and then that one main trunk would be more visible .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ky_palm064

Nice topic!

My oldest needle is bushy with lots of offsets, but my other one is single trunked. When it flowered a few years ago, it looked to be a female. There was a topic a couple of years ago about single trunked needles, which used the term "bull" only for the males.

 

needle02.thumb.JPG.b906eb17f9aaa0dddf5592eb964912fb.JPG

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teddytn
13 minutes ago, ky_palm064 said:

Nice topic!

My oldest needle is bushy with lots of offsets, but my other one is single trunked. When it flowered a few years ago, it looked to be a female. There was a topic a couple of years ago about single trunked needles, which used the term "bull" only for the males.

 

needle02.thumb.JPG.b906eb17f9aaa0dddf5592eb964912fb.JPG

 

Sometimes the simplest answer lol. I never even thought that might be the reason, that would be be cool to get to the bottom of. Nice reply!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jimhardy

looks like this thread is back on track but about as clear as mud now. :lol: 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teddytn

https://www.palmtalk.org/forum/index.php?/topic/44138-single-trunked-rhapidophyllum-hystrix-pictures/

Found the old thread, sorry for all the old heads that have to see repeated topics over and over. In the link above it didn’t seem like anyone got to the bottom of this either. People we’re reporting male and female single trunked specimens.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teddytn
12 minutes ago, Jimhardy said:

looks like this thread is back on track but about as clear as mud now. :lol: 

Haha the blind leading the blind here

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Will Simpson
On 4/30/2021 at 12:57 PM, teddytn said:

I remember seeing pictures of needle palms with a vertical solitary trunk and no lower fronds a long time ago. People were calling it a Bull needle. I’ve always been familiar with the “normal” clumping form which seems to grow wider with offsets as fast as it grows tall. I have one that’s been slow to grow period and only has a few small pups, but I don’t think is a “bull”. One normal clumping form and a small new clumping form. What’s everyone’s experience with the 2 different types? Let’s see them!!!

( Edit : I just noticed that teddytn found this article before me . )

 

This was on this discussion board back in 2014 :

 

 

 

Edited by Will Simpson
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
sashaeffer

It's been a while but I've seen before/after pictures of a trimmed up Needle palm that make it look like it was trunking. Looked really good as well.

 

So in that case, it wasn't a different variation but just trimmed to look that way.

I've done the same with a European fan palm that I have in the ground.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teddytn
1 hour ago, sashaeffer said:

It's been a while but I've seen before/after pictures of a trimmed up Needle palm that make it look like it was trunking. Looked really good as well.

 

So in that case, it wasn't a different variation but just trimmed to look that way.

I've done the same with a European fan palm that I have in the ground.

Yeah no I get that, if I trimmed the older leaves it would give that look for sure, but still trying to understand why some produce plentiful offsets and some are solitary. I read something a long time ago about plants in general, that if the environment where the plant is has ideal conditions it will put a lot of energy into reproduction, if the conditions are less than ideal the plant will put all its energy into trying to live indefinitely and not reproduce. Not sure if there is any correlation here.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
teddytn

This is the one I have that is more solitary 2 main trucks 1 pup per trunk. Just noticed it pushing flowers. Side note everything in the garden is pushing a ton of growth very early in the season. 201DE403-2E66-45AA-B125-BFF4BAE823A9.thumb.jpeg.c75246fd38c5b293fc97dc787e0772d6.jpegThe bigger clumping one has been flowering and producing unviable seed for 4 years I believe. I’ll take pics when it flowers. The inflorescence on the big one always seems underwhelming compared to the pic above. So are we talking male plant, female plant?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • maskedmole
      By maskedmole
      So I'm running out of room. Does it matter if I plant a trachycarpus only a few feet away from a southern magnolia or a needle palm? Or will they fight to the death over nutrients/water/sunlight? Does spacing really matter all that much?
    • teddytn
      By teddytn
      Walking around the yard weeding and watering and thought I would share some of what I have growing. Needle palms, sabal minor mccurtain, sabal minor, sabal Birmingham, various opuntias, yucca rostratas. 








    • Mr.SamuraiSword
      By Mr.SamuraiSword
      As I am presently living in Nashville, I wanted to get the scoop on palms in the area. On a FB palm group (NAPA I believe) I found a guy who lived in Henderson (20 minutes north of East Nashville) Tennessee who offered to show me some of the palms in the area.  I was very surprised that there were any unprotected palms besides Needles and Sabal minor, and was more surprised at how many I saw in a relatively small area.  Ill add he knew of more but It had gotten late, and we plan on doing another palm "hunt" in the future.
      First this large windmill palm near Old Hickory Lake.  According to the owner he bought two windmill palms about 15 - 17 years ago (this being one) while in Orlando around a 5 gallon size after asking about palms to grow in cold hardy climates.   Sadly the other one died (visible in photo) a few years ago after a winter, it simply declined and died.  The guy who was showing me around was pretty sure it wasn't cold damage as it was apparently a mild winter.  This palm has never been protected, and the trunk was about 17 feet tall.  

      Notice all these volunteers too.

      he also had a smaller one he planted around 8 years ago.  very fat trunk. More volunteers too.

      Few other Windmills around the area. This one on a property right on the lake.
      .
      Two more by a pool.

      The guy who I went with also had a very impressive garden.   He had some non palms that were still impressive But i will add those at the bottom of this post.
      Sabal palmetto, never protected, under a small roof area, planted 15 years ago.

      Another palmetto, this one's first winter.  Not bad damage considering this winter was colder then most, apparently duration wise.
      \
      Needle clump around 20 years old.

      Not sure the age on this one.

      Lots of nice Sabal Minor, some of these he believes aren't fully sabal because they have outgrown some other Sabal Minor he planted much earlier.  Either way he has around 20 - 25 planted around and had a literal bucket full of fresh seeds.
      These some of the self ID'd Lousiana, sold as Minor. He also said these would sometimes get very mild burn while the full minor didn't.  All were purchased as minor.  


      One in back right is Sabal Birmingham.  Two others are minor.

      These are apparently full Sabal Minor.  These were older then the others.


      Windmills too, planted around 8 years ago dont fully remember.  None of these palms have ever been protected I should add.


      Back near the lake, We also stopped at a place with two Sabal Palmetto palms. He apparently had never stopped here to ask so we did.  The owner said he dug up the "palm" in Jacksonville around 15 years ago.  He did not think It was a palmetto, though when we looked we decided it was, and told him as such.  apparently its slower then usual growth rate is due to the owner having a habit of cutting off all fronds with noticeable burn, and ice damage.  We also figured he thought it was a single palm and probably dug up several of them in the same place at once.  Also never protected.   


      At the Henderson Memorial park, apparently there used to be a Sabal Minor and Birmingham (the latter donated by my "guide"). The Birmingham died somehow, and the Minor was pulled out after over a decade to put in a trash can (yeah I know).  But down the peninsula, into the woods a little, were many Sabal Minor naturalizing littering the ground, near some swampy areas.  There was easily over 100 mixed in spread out over 100/100 feet 






      There were some other houses we passed by with palms,  he knew a person who owned this place, and apparently this a Sabal Birmingham. No other palms on the property

      Another windmill. Some of the plants looked like they had been wrapped including this, so we assume some fronds were cooked by Christmas lights. He intends to going back to warn them about it.
      Also 
      also a needle at the same place.

      Another home with large Sabal Minor.

      They also had a needle and a smaller Minor too.

      Now for some of his other rare non palms. Yucca aloifolia for starters. This area really seems like a 7b despite its zone designation.

      Sago Cycads, been there at least 5 years, come back every year as perenials. both have green here,

      Two live oaks laden with Spanish Moss.


      Some kind of Eucalyptus I forgot which one.

      I ended up getting one of the Large Windmill palms offspring while we visited.  I have since cleaned it and potted it better, this was the only photo I have.  

    • kbob11
      By kbob11
      Hi everyone,
         The weather is finally going to warm up a little starting next week.  My question is does anyone have experience with Needles consistently experiencing night time lows in the upper 20s?  I know that they can survive well below that for absolute lows but how about in and out of freezes?  I would like to air mine out as it has been covered in leaves and boxed since Thanksgiving.  Below is our extended forecast.  Thanks!

    • Landasaw
      By Landasaw
      So I have a place in my yard protected area zone 7A Hendersonville Tennessee. After a heavy rain there is sometimes standing water. Takes it a little longer to drain, but a palm would look good there so I was wondering about the various cultivars of dwarf palmetto and needle. Which one is tolerant of wet conditions and cold hardy?
×
×
  • Create New...