Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Bill H2DB

AP story on Fla Panhandle Freeze 4-17-14

Recommended Posts

displaced_floridian

Would you say this past winter was a 10-year or a 20-year event, or even more rare than that?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
palmsOrl

Here, a couple hundred miles away, it was a pretty ordinary winter. I bet you this winter was no more than a 1 in 10-15 year event. The lowest lows were FAR, FAR from all time record lows. The plants that have damage or were killed are probably almost all zone 9 stuff that does fine most winters in Panhandle areas near the coast. Zone 9 Phoenix species, queen palms, citrus and damage to Washingtonia robusta, etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
_Keith

20 year event.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Alicehunter2000

post-97-0-76966000-1397852846_thumb.jpg

Thought this shot of neighboring Alys Beach went with this story nicely.

Phoenix Dacts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
stevethegator

attachicon.gif20140407_164311.jpg

Thought this shot of neighboring Alys Beach went with this story nicely.

Phoenix Dacts.

Wow I've never seen that kind of damage on dates anywhere in FL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
palmsOrl

attachicon.gif20140407_164311.jpg

Thought this shot of neighboring Alys Beach went with this story nicely.

Phoenix Dacts.

Wow I've never seen that kind of damage on dates anywhere in FL

Woah, I haven't either! Those are solid zone 8b palms and Alys Beach is well east of Pensacola between Panama City and Fort Walton Beach (presumably a bit warmer than further west). Just how cold did it get there? Could it be from the duration of cold rather than just the absolute lows? How do the massive Phoenix dactylifera that are everywhere in New Orleans look?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
_Keith

attachicon.gif20140407_164311.jpg

Thought this shot of neighboring Alys Beach went with this story nicely.

Phoenix Dacts.

Wow I've never seen that kind of damage on dates anywhere in FL

Woah, I haven't either! Those are solid zone 8b palms and Alys Beach is well east of Pensacola between Panama City and Fort Walton Beach (presumably a bit warmer than further west). Just how cold did it get there? Could it be from the duration of cold rather than just the absolute lows? How do the massive Phoenix dactylifera that are everywhere in New Orleans look?

It wasn't the ultimate cold but a triple whammy of hits over 6-8 weeks. The northern gulf coast took a beating this year. It looks like that from Houston to Panama City.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Alicehunter2000

Mature canary and sylvestris also got popped pretty good. It was strange because there were individual palms of these same species that showed little damage around the area. The Alys Beach dacts also were subjected to stupidity on the part of their landscape crew. During the coldest parts of the freeze these geniuses decided to dig down around every single tree about 2 feet down severing all the feeder roots to install new lighting. It is a wonder that they are still alive. I mean they cut complete circles around about3 foot away from every single tree......they should have sprayed them with a herbicide too....just kidding. It was pretty ridiculous and could have resulted in the demise of the very things they were trying to enhance with lighting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Xerarch

attachicon.gif20140407_164311.jpg

Thought this shot of neighboring Alys Beach went with this story nicely.

Phoenix Dacts.

Wow I've never seen that kind of damage on dates anywhere in FL

Woah, I haven't either! Those are solid zone 8b palms and Alys Beach is well east of Pensacola between Panama City and Fort Walton Beach (presumably a bit warmer than further west). Just how cold did it get there? Could it be from the duration of cold rather than just the absolute lows? How do the massive Phoenix dactylifera that are everywhere in New Orleans look?

It wasn't the ultimate cold but a triple whammy of hits over 6-8 weeks. The northern gulf coast took a beating this year. It looks like that from Houston to Panama City.

Still, I'm surprised to see this much damage, I'd be interested to know what the absolute low was, I know AliceHunter's place got down to 19-20 for the absolute. I've seen these things take 16 degrees in the west without a scratch and these completely defoliate at 20? Even with repeated hits I'm surprised, or maybe the absolute was a lot less than 20 in some areas, or maybe this is just the difference of a humid climate. Anyway, sorry to see all this damage, looks like they will pull through though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Silas_Sancona

Fairly normal winter/ early spring here as well.. erring on a slightly cooler/ wetter angle this year. Also shocked to see and hear of the damage to such cold tolerant species up north.

-Nathan-

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
stevethegator

Something "unusual" must have happened as I am also surprised by all the damage Alicehunter and Keith have reported. Heavy Frost? The Palm Gods' infinite wrath?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
_Keith

The "unusual" was a cold snap for 3 days with a low of 21, then a few weeks later an ice storm low in upper 20s, then a couple weeks after that boom, another 3 day snap with low of 23.

Any of those alone, as happened in 2010 with a low of 19 would have been fine, but the 3 events in combination just sapped the life out of the palms and many other things as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
stevethegator

Yeah I can't believe how cold it's been this winter overall. It froze here in Atlanta a few days ago, the highs over the past couple days haven't climbed out of the 50s, and it looks like we may have 60/40 days going into May. Not to mention all the frozen precip, the single digits during the polar vortex, etc. Wacky!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
palmsOrl

I reviewed the data for the nearest official weather station in Panama City and there were several freezes with lows in the 20s this past winter-not surprising for the FL Panhandle. One freeze during the first half of January featured consecutive lows of 25F, 20F and 21F. 20F was the lowest recorded temperature of the winter there and that day only made it to 35F under fully clear skies for the entire day. There were other freezes that featured precipitation during the event, only officially recorded as rain though. Since Phoenix dactylifera is rated as hardy to 8b, I can't help but wonder if other factors, such as the root disturbance, etc are largely responsible for the damage.

What it comes down to for me is, the FL Panhandle had 10-20 year cold this winter, while in Orlando my unprotected royals are completely undamaged.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
_Keith

I reviewed the data for the nearest official weather station in Panama City and there were several freezes with lows in the 20s this past winter-not surprising for the FL Panhandle. One freeze during the first half of January featured consecutive lows of 25F, 20F and 21F. 20F was the lowest recorded temperature of the winter there and that day only made it to 35F under fully clear skies for the entire day. There were other freezes that featured precipitation during the event, only officially recorded as rain though. Since Phoenix dactylifera is rated as hardy to 8b, I can't help but wonder if other factors, such as the root disturbance, etc are largely responsible for the damage.

What it comes down to for me is, the FL Panhandle had 10-20 year cold this winter, while in Orlando my unprotected royals are completely undamaged.

Yes, you were lucky as these freezes did not penetrate deeply into Florida as did the one in the early 60s, and early and late 80s.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
spockvr6

What it comes down to for me is, the FL Panhandle had 10-20 year cold this winter, while in Orlando my unprotected royals are completely undamaged.

Yes, you were lucky as these freezes did not penetrate deeply into Florida as did the one in the early 60s, and early and late 80s.

http://www.reactiongifs.us/ill-be-back-terminator/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
palmsOrl

What it comes down to for me is, the FL Panhandle had 10-20 year cold this winter, while in Orlando my unprotected royals are completely undamaged.

Yes, you were lucky as these freezes did not penetrate deeply into Florida as did the one in the early 60s, and early and late 80s.

http://www.reactiongifs.us/ill-be-back-terminator/

LOL! True, but next time an 80s style freeze hits, it will have to overcome many miles of buildings, concrete/asphalt, automobiles, etc. (much of which was rural then) It has, in my experience been good for several degrees and the area continues to grow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Xenon

Houston doesn't look that bad...much better than 2010 freeze. Definitely no date palms like that...no damage at all. Queens look fine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jimbean

LOL! True, but next time an 80s style freeze hits, it will have to overcome many miles of buildings, concrete/asphalt, automobiles, etc. (much of which was rural then) It has, in my experience been good for several degrees and the area continues to grow.

I would only add about 1.5F to 2F in urban areas.

So if Orlando's all time record low is 18F, then that same cold spell would mean about 20F.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
palmsOrl

I guess it depends on the urban area in question, Jim. Based on my experience and actual weather data, the urban core of Orlando is easily 4-5F warmer on low temperatures on the coldest nights than rural areas in all directions from the city. The exceptions are rare advective freeze events, where temperatures tend to be more even area-wide, with a gradual temp increase from north to south. The last true advective freeze here was January 24, 2003, when the temp at the official reporting stations reached 27F, city, burbs and rural. In 2010, temps in the suburbs of Orlando reached 24F officially(25F at my house in Maitland), while the near-downtown station only reached 29F. I've actually read that the urban heat islands of the NE megalopolis can keep temperatures on cold nights in excess of 10F above those in adjacent rural areas and I believe it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dave-Vero

The cold really didn't penetrate much into the peninsula. Our local low for the winter seems to have bee 30 F on Jan. 19, which didn't bother anything.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
NorthFlpalmguy

It was more of the duration of the low 20s than the absolute lows. That January continous freeze was the big killer IMO. I think it is more of a 10 yr event if that. It seems to have reminded palm buyers along the gulf coast to stick to what we grow locally- butias, trachys, sabals, washys, med/euro fan, etc. I had no more small 3G palms die than normal (like 6 in 3,000). I know of a few established dactyliferas that were burnt badly but look like they will survive and those are much more inland than the coast.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Alicehunter2000

They ended up replacing 4 of those P. dacts in the picture. Full crowns have not yet established on the remaining ones....and here comes another winter..........Sucks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Matthew92

It was weird- similarly, I saw P. dactyliferas on the barrier island that were very damaged and died while at the same time 20 miles to the north on the mainland there was a planting of full sized ones that had 75% leaf burn but resumed growth very quickly.

Edited by Opal92

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • rfielding
      By rfielding
      Hello all, 
      I'm a geographer based in South Carolina, but a Florida native, with an interest in breadfruit as a tool for food security. I'm especially interested in efforts to push the latitudinal boundaries of breadfruit, including the good work that many are doing to grow breadfruit in Florida. I'd love to hear from members of this forum on their efforts to grow breadfruit in Florida or other places where it's challenging. Feel free to reply here or email me directly at rfielding@coastal.edu. Thanks very much!
      Russell Fielding
      Coastal Carolina University 
    • TampaPalms
      By TampaPalms
      Today I went ahead and added some Epsom salt to my arecas and foxtail palm. I was at thinking of adding a light light palm fertilizer to them especially the arecas to keep them nice and green as we just had a cold snap. I am in zone 9B in Tampa. Anyone in 9B or 10A have luck fertilizing palms in the winter? I'm afraid if I do so we will have another borderline freeze the new growth will be more susceptible to be killed.
    • kinzyjr
      By kinzyjr
      NOAA makes weather records from the Florida stations available to download for free.  Out of the 1,700+ stations, 358 contain at least some temperature data.  If one were to download all of these records, import them into a database, and use some crafty SQL queries to generate sheets for each of the impact freezes it would provide a really good side-by-side resource to compare the microclimates in each region of Florida.
      That is exactly what has been done with the 0000_202011040720_F_SQL_v2.xlsx spreadsheet attached to this post.  Each tab in the spreadsheet contains records for one of our unfortunate cold events.  The records come sorted first by the TAG column, which represents one of the areas in the pictures and is defined by a set of latitude and longitude boundaries.  A second sort is by the station name alphabetically.  This gives you a region of weather stations sorted alphabetically that allows you to see the temperatures in the region beside each other.
      The lists are able to be filtered or sorted in any way you choose, so if you are only interested in weather stations in a particular region or set of regions, this is easily accomplished.  For easy viewing, the rows for each region alternate in shading.  This is easy to remove or change if you wish.
      If you would like to see the boundaries of a region, the weather stations used with a link to their corresponding Weather Underground station, or a listing of the freezes and some commentary lifted from Florida Citrus Mutual’s website, or a description of the station location, the 202007121300_NOAA_WeatherStations_TemperatureOnly.xlsx sheet will have a plethora of this information.
      For anyone who likes to look at the various airport weather stations on Wunderground, 202004292350_AirportWeatherStations.xlsx will give you as complete listing of these stations as I could assemble.
      Now for a description of the various TAGs:
      PEN = Pensacola area

      PAN - Panama City Area

      TAL - Tallahassee Area

      EPN - Eastern Panhandle

      CNF - Central North Florida

      JAX - Jacksonville area

      NEF - Northeast Florida - Dayona + St. Augustine and surrounding area

      NWC - Northwest Central Florida

      SWC - Southwest Central Florida

      NIC - North Inland Central Florida

      SIC - South Inland Central Florida

      ECF - East Central Florida

      SWF - Southwest Florida

      SEF - Southeast Florida

      MUK - Miami and the Upper Keys

      KEY - The South and Western Florida Keys

      0000_202011040720_F_SQL_v2.xlsx 202007121300_NOAA_WeatherStations_TemperatureOnly.xlsx 202004292350_AirportWeatherStations.xlsx
    • kinzyjr
      By kinzyjr
      While perusing a few threads referencing the 1835 freeze, 1894-1895 freeze and the 1899 freeze, there were a few mentions of this book.  There are used copies available on Amazon for less than $20 so I decided to order it.  After reading it, I’d certainly recommend it.  While the content is presented primarily from the point of view of someone interested in commercial citrus growing, the information about each of the events is certainly relevant to palm horticulture.
      The book was a welcome relief from staring at a screen all day after working a job that typically centers around doing the same.  There are a lot of references and to the small cities throughout the state since they are typically where citrus is grown, and the weather data is obviously of interest to anyone growing palms since the same freezes are typically what impacts what is long-term or bulletproof in an area.
      The book contained weather records and quotes from the various growers as well as descriptions of the weather before and after the freeze.  Some of the quotes are humorous in spite of the fact that these folks likely lost a lot of money due to these events.  Almost all areas are at least represented in the weather records, including Key West in some cases.
      There are actually two freezes from California noted in the book (1937 and 1990).  In my case, the book does provide some weather readings from Lakeland City Hall rather than the airport, and has some weather readings from Bok Tower to compare to the Mammoth Grove area in Lake Wales to illustrate the difference elevation makes during a radiational event vs. an advective event.  There is also information on a few of our early and late season frosts that have the potential to impact tropical plants and citrus alike.  There book also covers an inverted freeze, where north and central Florida were not impacted as harshly as south Florida. 
      The cover photo actually came from our local newspaper, The Ledger.
      As the book was released in 1997, the 1996 freeze is the last one fully covered.  If you want a screen break and you like the data on the weather forums - give this one a read.
      Book Information: A History of Florida Citrus Freezes by John A. Attaway, Ph.D. (June 1st, 1997)
      Amazon Listing: https://www.amazon.com/John-Attaway/dp/0944961037/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=A+History+of+Florida+Citrus+Freezes&qid=1599060452&sr=8-1
      Some links posted by @richtrav @tropical1 and @Matthew92 referencing this book:
      https://www.palmtalk.org/forum/index.php?/topic/4720-long-and-lat/&do=findComment&comment=81717
      https://www.palmtalk.org/forum/index.php?/topic/9124-freezing-degree-hours/&do=findComment&comment=153877
      https://www.palmtalk.org/forum/index.php?/topic/9289-what-is-a-dewpoint/&do=findComment&comment=157382
      https://www.palmtalk.org/forum/index.php?/topic/59364-orlando-area-winters-recent-trends-and-history/

    • missknich
      By missknich
      Need help identifying this palm tree. Thank you.

×
×
  • Create New...